Closed Confrontation PV Edwin & Eonaria

IC Time: 3:40pm, November 15th, 2024

XXXEdwin claimed that he only spoke the harsh truth, causing Eonaria to snort slightly. Does he really not see how insulting his words are? There could literally be werewolf students standing in this courtyard right now. But she was startled when he turned directly to face her and asked her a question: "If this potion is so effective at dealing with werewolves, why is there so many newly turned werewolves?" Oliver seemed to tense up, waiting for her answer as well. Luckily, she drew up a response almost at once.

XXX"Well, I'm not really sure what he means by 'the potion can't be forgotten' since anyone could make a mistake and forget to take a potion. Then it is the fault of the... condition. Accidents do not reflect on the nature of the actual person. I'm sure there must be perfectly kind and intelligent werewolves. Yes, it is a terrible thing that werewolves are possibly attacking children on purpose, but it is due to the nature of the person behind the werewolf. A werewolf might attack and turn a child, but isn't it also true that completely average humans also may attack children?" She crossed her arms.

XXX"That's the whole point of Azkaban and Muggle jails: there are terrible people who do terrible things. It's usually not because they are werewolves. Some of them are just immoral people. But most werewolves are not immoral people, just like most wizards are not immoral people. So stop assuming all werewolves are bad and need to be thrown out of Hogwarts! They deserve a chance at education just like the rest of us!" Eonaria exhaled, finally finished. Wow, it seems like I rant a lot about werewolves. She narrowed her eyes at Edwin, wondering what kind of argument he had to back up his beliefs. I basically just wrote a whole essay out loud-

.・-: ✧☾♩♪♩♬　. 。・ ゜✭・.・✫ ゜・。.　♬♩♪♩☽✧ :-・.

"Oliver here," He gestured to Oliver, as Eonaria finished her defences. "was the one that made the claim that no werewolf would ever forget the potion. He even said he'd be willing to bet on that. You're supporting my arguement." He began with a grin, his eyes flicking over towards Oliver.

"And again, this is all really falling back onto what my arguement with Oliver stemmed from." He continued, his tone reverting back to his typical, bored drawl. His gaze flicking between the two as he spoke, more than confident in his ability to continue with this arguement. "I made the claim that the wolfsbane potion isn't an adequate solution to the issue, which you're arguement is backing up what I claimed. The fault is the werewolves, yes. This potion simply isn't the fix all Oliver claimed it to be, you are still getting transformations after all. Sure, maybe there are intelligent werewolves." He shrugged, sounding as if he didn't even believe that claim. "But that intelligence is thrown out the window once a month, when they are forced to be some slobbering mutt, and in the midst of suffering with some.. Illness." He hesitated for a moment, his eyes narrowing as he fixed his gaze upon Oliver for a moment longer than he had done previously. His voice trailed off completly, a moment of silence hanging between the three as Edwins mind began to race between ideas. His recent obsession paired with Astrology lessons had made him incredibly conscious of the moon cycle, especially considering how the moon would rise tonight. Surely not.. He thought, continuing to look at Oliver. Just a coincidence, I'm sure.

"Where was I.." He muttered, his confidence seemingly having been shook by some revelation that neither Oliver nor Eonaria were privy to. "Bringing humans into an arguement about werewolves is weak, never once did I claim otherwise, nor is it relevent to the discussion. I also never once claimed they should be thrown out of hogwarts, you are just assuming things here." Correctly assuming things, he thought but that wasa not something he would share.

"Truthfully," He continued to stare back at Oliver. "Not sure your friend has aided much in their defence. Some of what she said actually supported my arguement, did it not?"