Recommendations for best Harry Potter game - page 1 - The Counter Chat

8 May 2026, 13:16

Playing Hogwarts Legacy right now. Such a stunning game in terms of visuals and story. Any recommendations on which Harry Potter games to play next? I've never played any of the classic games, which is both sad and exciting because I have much to explore

Winter Angelo

Second year, Broom Racer, Slytherin

1 703 96

8 May 2026, 14:18

Maybe be Hogwarts: a mystery? Or the classic hio jk

Winter A.\| Seasonal Shop\|Pin	sta • 6 \| eva • 7 \| str • 6
"Stay determined, stay unbeatable!"	wis • 7 \| arc • 6 \| acc • 8

Gideon Bellix

Second year, Gryffindor

21 24

8 May 2026, 15:52

Classic hio is

haha
Hogwarts: a Mystery looks cool! I'll check it out. Thanks

Avery Gray

Third year, Quidditch player, Gryffindor

13 658 575

8 May 2026, 15:57

Hogwarts Mystery is a lot of fun and I highly recommend if you want to play a HP game set about 7 years before Harry Potter went to Hogwarts. I'm currently a 5th (nearly 6th) year on there!

Avery Gray	Be the change you wish to see	Dylan Astor
Avery's Creations	in the world.	Dylan's Electric Creations

Lauren Vanes

Second year, Slytherin

3 421 89

8 May 2026, 15:58

H.
I.
O.

For sure

𝓼𝓽𝓪 2 \| 𝓮𝓿𝓪 3 \| 𝓼𝓽𝓻 1 \| 𝔀𝓲𝓼 8 \| 𝓪𝓻𝓬 8 \| 𝓪𝓬𝓬 8	XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX	lauren vanes \| parselmouth
	❝kill them with success and bury them with a smile.❞

Gideon Bellix

Second year, Gryffindor

21 24

8 May 2026, 16:07

Avery Gray wrote: 8 May 2026, 15:57 Hogwarts Mystery is a lot of fun and I highly recommend if you want to play a HP game set about 7 years before Harry Potter went to Hogwarts. I'm currently a 5th (nearly 6th) year on there!

Heard great things about Hogwarts Mystery, will check it out for sure!

Gideon Bellix

Second year, Gryffindor

21 24

8 May 2026, 16:09

Lauren Vanes wrote: 8 May 2026, 15:58 H.
I.
O.

For sure

I'm new here, but I have to say HIO is certainly the most immersive Hogwarts experience I've had

Melissa Blake

First year, Gryffindor

1 490 6

8 May 2026, 16:14

I gotta say Hogwarts Mystery but H.io is a lot better cause I get to interact with actual ppl for once

ℳℯ𝓁𝒾𝓈𝓈𝒶 ℬ𝓁𝒶𝓀ℯ

"Just because you put a piece of smelly Camembert in a box doesn't stop it from smelling."

Zach Zaphiere

Fifth year, Broom racer, Ravenclaw

1 488 718

8 May 2026, 16:21

Harry Potter: Magic Awakened is also fun.

Characters: Zach Zaphiere | Lesmana Asmaralaya | Kanthil Kinanthi

Gideon Bellix

Second year, Gryffindor

21 24

8 May 2026, 16:27

Melissa Blake wrote: 8 May 2026, 16:14 I gotta say Hogwarts Mystery but H.io is a lot better cause I get to interact with actual ppl for once

For sure that. And also being in control of your own story, rather than being locked into some Main Quest like most video games.

Back Reply

Winter A.\| Seasonal Shop\|Pin	sta • 6 \| eva • 7 \| str • 6
"Stay determined, stay unbeatable!"	wis • 7 \| arc • 6 \| acc • 8