Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED

Luna OR Hermione?
I would like to discuss who is better: Luna OR Hermione. Many people think Hermione I would like to know their reasons! Have fun! (I support Luna though)

Also if you answer the question above please post why below!
Last edited by Edith Walkers on 27 Aug 2025, 12:48, edited 3 times in total.
Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED
I like them both, but I prefer Hermione because I relate to her in a couple ways such as I’m also a bookworm, I’m a Gryffindor IRL, and I like cats too but they aren’t my favorite animal.

Be the change you wish to see
in the world.
Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED
Why I like Luna:
Reducio
I prefer Luna because we share the same house, and I always thought her rather clever even though she was a bit odd. She was very unique, and always sided with the truth rather than what the community wanted to think. She was a great character but not many people single her out because even though she played a very big role, no one really seems to notice it.

Why I dislike Hermione and Luna
Reducio
I also think that Hermione kind of... only believed what she saw with her eye, or read about. She also thought that she was right most of the time and had many flaws,
Going to Xenophillius Lovegood (book 7), assuming Snape was trying to harm Harry, (book 1), liking Lockhart just for his looks (book 2), going with Mclaggen just for revenge (book 6), she thought Ron was bad at Quidditch and refused to believe that he didn't use Felix Felsis until it got proven to her, (book 6), and dismissing Harry suspicions about Draco having to do something with Voldemort (book 6).
These are just a few flaws of her character, but she also had many good things too. I'm not trying to say that Luna was a flawless character,
She had a lack of definite proof, she believed in such things as crumpled Horned Snorkacks, she had a lot of faith in the Quibbler even though it had a bit rubbish things in it, her beliefs often contrasted slightly with those of Hermione and Harry and Ron, (who had proof)
, but just that there is not a particular scene where Luna was wrong.
Conclusion:
Reducio
I also like her mystic character and the way she never seemed really upset when bullied. She also made great progress in the DA along with Neville and Ginny. This is why I prefer Luna, but feel free to disagree and explain your views!
Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED
Luna:
She always seemed slightly odd, slightly unique. She’s different and I really like that about her. Also, she doesn’t let other people’s comments get to her (at least not outwardly) which is quite admirable.

Hermione:
She’s smart, loves to read, and is overall very learning oriented. She’s brave and quite loyal to her friends. She’s also passionate and doesn’t let other people sway her beliefs.

Conclusion:
I like both Hermione and Luna because they are both strong female characters in their own ways. Additionally, I honestly see myself (OOC) in both of them.

Be the hero or be the villain, it doesn’t matter, just be happy, be you, and be the main character in your story.
Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED
I don't see myself in any of them, but honestly OOC I look a bit like Ginny
Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED
I like both of them, I like how cool Luna is, and that Hermione is a bookworm (I am too). But the thing that I like Luna better for than Hermione is that Luna likes animals.
Is it Luna OR Hermione? CLOSED
I am closing this thread because I have too many games and it is hard to control and update every single one.

Some of my most successful:
Please have a go at those! :)